Talkin' Mets Reviews

Rate us Rate us on Apple Podcasts
on 11/7/2026 PA Mets fan

Loved the podcast with Evan Roberts
view on Apple Podcasts

on 6/3/2026 My Fave Mets Podcast

Hey Mike, thanks for all the great shows and insights you provide us. And for helping to get us through this disappointing & frustrating season! A note from this past week’s extended episode. I thought Steve Keane was fantastic. I think you should bring him on a few times a season to chop it up. Thanks and LGM!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 4/12/2026 Love this show!!

Keep up the great work thank you so much, love your knowledge of the game and the team.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 1/6/2026 No spin. Straight talk

I appreciate how Mike Silva doesn’t do the typical click-bait show. He tells it like it is(even if we don’t want to hear it), no spin, no bull. Keep up the good work!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 11/27/2023 Must listen for every Mets fan

My favorite Mets podcast …highly recommended
view on Apple Podcasts

on 10/2/2023 My lifeline to Mets baseball from the UK

Been a huge fan of Mike’s podcast for over a decade and his perspective on Mets baseball is flawless. Starts my week every Monday on a perfect note, keep up the great work, Mike
view on Apple Podcasts

on 4/24/2023 Announcers

Love the show, the variety, the attitude. I was slightly disappointed that the announcer discussion didn’t name check Bob Uecker. Even during his career as a TV clown, he was a great radio voice — and never stopped doing it
view on Apple Podcasts

on 3/30/2023 Relevant, informative and entertaining

I have been listening to Mile Silva’s talkin Mets Podcast for several years and as a Met fan I find the topics relevant, informative, and entertaining. I don’t always share Mike’s opinion about the topics, as a matter of fact I disagree about half the time but it’s what I enjoy most about the show. Mike gets you to think, and is not afraid to be critical of the Mets. Thanks for the content Mike. Well done.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 3/6/2023 Reminds me of WFAN

Grew up in NJ listening to WFAN and loved the Mets coverage. Now many miles from NY, my Mets news comes from podcasts, and Talkin Mets gives me deep coverage from unique angles.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 2/6/2023 Mets theme

Love the podcast and love the opening when it starts with an interview clip and goes into he 70’s Mets theme! So keep the 70’s Mets theme!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 1/30/2023 Good show

Enjoy the show. Started rooting for the Mets in the late 70s, and it’s a good show to keep me up to date.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 1/30/2023 Metlicious

Really enjoy listening to this podcast Mike is very informative and he has a very (re)fresh way of informing us and getting his opinion across and that’s what is great about baseball everyone has their own opinion about the sport and their team. I have always loved everything about baseball and especially New York baseball (that’s why I hate the Yankees so much) but Being born, raised and living in Melbourne Australia I crave anything Mets and Mike puts you right in the middle of it!! Keep it up Mike I love your take on baseball and the Mets, you are very knowledgeable fair and thought provoking thank you for that. LGM
view on Apple Podcasts

on 1/19/2023 Best Mets podcast

Very insightful, intelligent discussion about our Metropolitans. Don’t always agree with Mike’s assessments but he makes valid arguments.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 12/30/2022 Integrity

Mike is a true independent and reasoned voice who is not afraid to buck the trends.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 12/30/2022 Entertaining

Mr Silva has the gift of gab. No nonsense, informative but also interesting opinions and insights. If you like the Mets, you’ll like Mike.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 11/12/2022 Long Time Listener

Been listening since the end of 2016. Mike does a great job discussing the past, present, and future of the Mets. He's very authentic and a pleasure to listen to. Keep it up Mike!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 10/11/2022 Long Time Mets Fan Here

I don’t always agree with Mike but I thoroughly enjoy his show. I tune in every week. He does a great job with his analysis. The sincerity he showed in the final episode to the listeners felt authentic. Mike, as you have said Buck was a great hire. He kept the team focused all season and he deserves credit for up leveling the culture and quality of play. Having said all that, Buck has some ‘splaining to do about why the team didn’t show the focus and fight it had all season in the two biggest series. The bar has been raised like you said but Buck needed to deliver that message to the team in the final stretch. He didn’t and I suspect that was a lost opportunity. Buck doesn’t need to go. He needs to prove he’s learned from this experience.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 10/11/2022 Enjoyable

Intelligent discussions… loved 2022 season wrap up…LFGM!!!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 10/11/2022 Most thoughtful and best Mets podcast out there

I love Mike’s balanced and knowledgeable and positive shows. This is my favorite Mets podcast by far.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 10/11/2022 Keep speaking the truth

Love this podcast, keep speaking the truth and the honesty . Let’s go Mets …
view on Apple Podcasts

on 10/11/2022 Thank You

Thank you Mike for help putting some closure on this great season. I too need a break and just can’t watch playoffs this week. Ive enjoyed hearing your coverage and analysis all year.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 10/11/2022 Thanks

Keep it up, Mike. I look forward to your show. Heartbreak, indeed. But it was a helluva season; loads of fun, great memories, pretty magical. Bummer of an end but look how far we’ve come. Took the Mets 84 and 85 to get to 86…Let’s Go Mets!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 10/6/2022 Still the best Mets podcast

I don’t always agree with him but he’s fun to listen to and he knows his stuff.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 9/9/2022 Mets vs Historic Run Episode

EXACTLY what I needed! As a 60 yr old lifelong Mets fan, I too feel the “irrational fear.” Each game was affecting my life to the point of needing to completely disconnect and only check the scores. This podcast episode was the medicinal emotional rehab I needed to have. Balanced, honest, rational and intelligent. Thanks again, No G’! You’re the best in the biz. Your Pal, @JerseyJoe75
view on Apple Podcasts

on 8/3/2022 Best Mets Pod available

Definitely my go to Mets Podcast. Mike has the best takes and best feel for the team. I look forward to the podcast every week. I can’t wait to hear how Mike feels about the trade deadline. Must listen for real Mets Fans who want honest breakdowns and realistic views on the team.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 7/29/2022 All things Mets

I really enjoy Mike Silva’s podcast. His commentary on the Mets is grounded on reality, facts, and common sense. I like how he switches between the past, present, and future. It’s an easy listen as I walk my dog. Great job Mike!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 6/2/2022 Great Podcast!

Mike is awesome! He is insightful, balanced, extremely knowledgeable and fun to listen to. I read the negative reviews and just shake my head. This is one of the better Mets podcasts.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 6/2/2022 Best Mets podcast

I’ve listened to all the Mets podcasts out there, this is my favorite. Mike does a fantastic job covering the Mets every week with great balanced takes and analysis of the team.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 6/1/2022 In Buck (and Mike) we trust⚾️

Found Mike’s podcast in early March and have enjoyed it since. Mike is a Mets fan but not a homer and is knowledgeable, objective and brings his opinions both good and critical. It’s a bar convo or backyard with some buddies or a random fan talkin Mets baseball. Thanks Mike and LGM!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 5/27/2022 LFGM!!!

Mike you’re an incredible host and have made an amazin’ podcast! Don’t listen to the people who say you’re negative, I’m from south Texas and trust me everyone in this state is actually negative to the Mets. So listening to your pod is a nice refresher from someone who actually watches the team. …oh and yes I’d love to see Pete do cartwheels around the bases and maybe roll to home plate like a bowling ball or something but that’s just me lol
view on Apple Podcasts

on 4/28/2022 Talkin Mets podcast

Mike does an outstanding job on this podcast. He brings his own wisdom , life experience, knowledge of the Mets , media , baseball and overall perspectives into his pod. I really appreciate how hard he tries to create balance, which is unusual in New York podcasts. I really enjoy his monologues. I do wish he would have more hallmark guests, as he is an excellent interviewer and listener. I really don’t agree with all of his perspectives, but I appreciate his explanations for his point of view. If you are a met fan, especially out of the New York market, like me, you will look forward to his podcast. Five stars for sure.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 1/5/2022 People let politics get in the way

if you’re a lefty snowflake you’ll get triggered because he spits the truth.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 12/23/2021 Great Perspective

Mike is very knowledgeable and has great takes. You may not agree with everything he says but he always has the facts to back up his opinion and if you wait long enough, it usually turns out to be right. Give it a listen, you won’t be disappointed.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 6/29/2021 Great podcast

Mike does a very thorough and balanced take on my beloved Mets. As a fan of the Mets my whole life he gives a good balance of realism and pessimism. Unfortunately I am more pessimistic but I still love them amazins. Lfgm. Ohh Frank the tank maybe the worst guest and probably the most inarticulate human being I have ever heard. Your better off doing the show solo. His review. and analysis consists of cursing and rambling. Moreover, I think if you just found a random New Yorker he would be a better podcast guest.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 6/20/2021 A highlight of my week

I’ve lived in Manchester, UK for my entire life and I became a Mets fan when I was 15 years old in 2003. Over the years its been hard to find completely unbiased, balanced and independent views from real Mets fans as I have nobody to talk baseball with thousands of miles away from Shea/Citi. All I ever had were biased mainstream media viewpoints until I discovered Mikes podcast and I never looked back. I’m a New York sports fan living in the UK which makes finding truly great content a challenge; podcasts for the teams I support are often littered with endorsements, ads or clearly biased towards a mainstream media agenda but the Talkin’ Mets podcast (along side a certain New York Jets podcast ive loved for over 10 years) is the only one that showcases true independence in thought, opinion and content. I listen religiously every Monday morning which is when the new episodes drop in the UK and it is a true highlight of my week. These episodes are consistent in quality, timing and length and personally I value that a lot. I also value the authenticity and honesty that Mike brings to any discussion and regardless of whether I agree with him or not, he makes me think instead of doing what I feel a lot of podcast hosts do these days and just try and force their opinions on you. Five star, well informed Amazin’ podcast and one for all fanatical and causal Mets fan alike the world over
view on Apple Podcasts

on 6/8/2021 Great show!

Mike does a thorough job of evaluating what’s going on. He has an honest perspective on the team’s status. He raises interesting questions and keeps the listener engaged in the show.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 6/7/2021 Josh S

Mike is both knowledgeable and fair, which is rare in today’s media. While columnists in the post and the daily news root for drama and clicks, Mike is informative and accurate. I highly recommend the pod as an effective foil to the traditional media that covers the Mets.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 6/7/2021 A Mets must listen

I’m coming late to the Talkin Mets podcast - have been a UK based Mets fans for over 30 years. Mike’s show is a must listen podcast once it drops on Monday (preferably Monday morning Mike 😉) I’ve read a couple of additional books that I hadn’t heard of before his podcast - and that’s a quality service 👍
view on Apple Podcasts

on 6/3/2021 Insightfs on NY Mets

Mike Silva's Talkin' Mets is the go-to NY Mets podcast. Mike offers his frank reviews of the players, the team, and management on a weekly basis. Good place to check in on what's going on with the Mets and MLB. Been listening for a while, and check in weekly during the season, and in the weeks leading up to the new season. Higly recommend.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 5/31/2021 Great Listen For Any Met but A Must for U.K. Mets

Mike is the kind of guy you could meet in a bar and before you know it it’s closing time and you’ve been there all day. Sure he’s media type knowledgeable but what comes across more than that is that he’s a fan. A must listen, in my opinion, for Mets all over and especially those of us in foreign lands who don’t get to talk baseball that often. Keep up the good work and Let’s Go Mets!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 5/4/2021 Talkin’ Mets - Talkin’ Great Podcast

Outstanding podcast. Mike is a knowledgeable and fair in all Met’s matters. Love the format and guests. Only wish we could hear more of this talk each week!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 3/9/2021 Talkin Mets

If you are looking for Mets talk this is the podcast. Stumbled upon it since spring training is here and keeps me entertained and love the takeaways. Keep up the good work!!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 3/1/2021 Mike is alright

Love the straight talk, lots of good info and interesting guests. More insight than I was expecting, plus no politics. I’m a fan!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 2/21/2021 Calling it like it is

“There is no benefit for the media when you’re happy.” Amazing quote. Thank you for being honest about what should be a cautiously optimistic year for the Mets.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 2/1/2021 Legit Mets Podcast

Mike, life long Mets fan. I enjoy many Mets podcasts but yours stands up as podcasts about the Mets for real Met fans. Alway in depth and audio quality is good. Good luck and I hope for many more Mets podcasts.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 1/25/2021 Diversity

Mike, your take on diversity is spot on thank you for your unbiased perspective. I listen religiously and mostly agree with you. Not always but that’s to be expected.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 1/21/2021 Mets in the UK!

It’s hard to find great Mets content in the UK. I went to Citi Field to watch the Mets against the Braves back in September 2019 and have been into Baseball ever since! Keep up the good work, you give a great insight into everything Mets related
view on Apple Podcasts

on 1/18/2021 Great Mets program

Mike is fantastic he brings a great perspective to what is happening with the Mets. He has a great mix of guests and information shows that are always relevant to what is happening with the Mets and baseball. As a Mets fan not living in New York he really gives great content!! Love the podcast!!!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 1/17/2021 Great perspective and very honest

Mike you are great to listen to. I can’t say I agree with everything but I enjoy the variety of Mets topics that you cover. I truly enjoy your perspective of the team, the business of the game and where the players heads might be at. You are very professional and you are great o listen to on a weekly basis. Thank you
view on Apple Podcasts

on 1/14/2021 Really good show with honest, unvarnished opinions about the Mets

I listen to a number of Mets podcasts, but Talkin’ Mets is one that I consider can’t-miss. Mike Silva is not a shill by any means. He calls it like he sees it and while I don’t always agree with his opinions—and we’ve discussed a few times on Twitter—I appreciate the thoughtful insight every week.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 1/14/2021 Silva

In this day and age, if you are a Mets fan, you must be listening to Silva. He’s well informed. He’s engaging. He’s thoughtful, and he explains his analysis. Are you looking for someone to shock you? Don’t look here. Are you looking for someone to shout mindless invective all day long? Don’t look here. Are you looking for someone who will criticize just to criticize and then not be accountable? Don’t look here. Are you looking for a hater who hates just to hate? Don’t look here. Are you looking for someone who is not shy about his opinion? Mike Silva Want someone who you can respect, even when you disagree? Mike Silva Want a good interviewer who understands the subtleties and nuances and history of the game, and of the New York Mets? Mike Silva If you are a true Mets fan, and you want to hear a) what is going on; b) an informed and engaging analysis of what is going on; c) someone who remains accountable - Mike Silva is the one for you. I do not agree with everything he says - not by a long shot. But he explains why he says what he says, and he deepens my appreciation for his analysis, even if I still don’t agree. It is fun to be a Mets fan. It is more fun to be a Mets fan after listening to Silva. Let’s. Go. Mets.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 1/8/2021 True quality Mets content.

With so many Mets podcast it’s often hard to find the really good one. This one is it. Real insight. Informative. And fun. Thank you.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 12/16/2020 Excellent Mets Insight

Great podcast and Mike does a great job. Happy to discover this right before the season and can't wait to listen all year ! Thanks
view on Apple Podcasts

on 8/30/2020 Excellent Show

A true voice of the fans. Great stuff!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 8/22/2020 New to baseball

Growing up and living in England. Baseball isn’t a big thing. So me and the wife went to citi field last September it was a eye opener for me. I love the sport! This podcast has become the highlight of my week. Keep up the good work 👍🏼
view on Apple Podcasts

on 8/1/2020 Good Listen

Been listening to this for a couple of years. I’ve tried other Mets podcasts but they are so unprofessional. Mike knows how to speak clearly and his radio experience is evident...yes presentation matters. Mike will tell you what he thinks, and you can agree or disagree, but it’s good for thought either way. Reading these other reviews where obviously their political mindset gets easily offended...there’s no politics involved...but if your obsessed with politics you can read that into it. If so that’s on you.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 7/5/2020 A classic Brooklyn baseball fan who knows his Mets

I am an unlikely listener. I tend to like fangraphs/ heavily analytical podcasts more than “opinion” style podcast. (Although most baseball podcasts pretty much rely on some form of opinion no matter how deeply reliant on analytics they are for their analysis). Mike doesn’t reject analytics, but he also marries human personality, heart, history and facts with his assessments. I think that’s all you can really ask for right? I like this podcast bc it balances out my studying of the game. But he’s no dummy and doesn’t reject new age information. Plus his guests are who you’d want on a mets podcast. Normally don’t give 5 stars but I reserve that for the really professional podsters out there and he is one of them.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 4/30/2020 Great podcast + topic suggestion

I was 9 years old in 1956 when I attended my first ballgame at Ebbets Field. It was the last regular season game, Brooklyn won the game 8-6 against Pittsburgh, Newcombe won his 27th game, Duke hit 2 homers to win NL homer title with 43 HRs, the win clinched the pennant on the last day/season and it turned out to Jackie’s final regular season game (he hit a homer, too). So I was hooked on baseball. A year or so later I got my first life lesson with a broken heart when the Dodgers did the unthinkable and moved away. As a kid I hated the Yankees. No way they could be my new team. And then there was talk of a new NL NY team. The selection of the name Mets was a head scratcher. Didn’t like the sound of it. I thought Metros sounded better. Still do. But whatever. I liked the selection of royal blue but would’ve liked blue, white and red numerals. But oh well. I was glad to have a local team to root for and their ineptitude was endearing. Every one of those 40 first wins felt like David slaying the Goliath. So a suggestion for a show - a deep dig into the genesis of the re-entry of NL baseball in NY. Keep up the great work, Mike.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 3/19/2020 Thanks

Thanks Mike for this awesome podcast! Would love to hear some more throwback interviews. Yes we all do need a distraction from everything that is going on right now. Can’t get enough baseball talk!!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 3/3/2020 Love the show!

Great Mets Podcast. Mike Silva always knowledgeable. Love the ending song. My favorite version of the mets theme!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 2/9/2020 The voice you need to hear

Talkin Mets is the voice Mets fans need to hear because it has a unique perspective, and is very well reasoned. Mike Silva speaks truth to power AND to the hive mentality with unique insight and perspective. If you need proof, go back and listen to how Mike treated the 1. Callaway firing, 2. Beltran hiring, 3. Astros cheating scandal, 4. Beltran firing, and 5. The whole Steve Cohen affair. More importantly, listen to what he said BEFORE these events broke. He's not a clairvoyant, he just uses his experience and knowledge and shoes away from wild speculation of the type that gets radio ratings and Twitter clicks. Mike has always been there and his view is smart and does not feed into the typical rabid fans' fantasies of bloodlust. You will walk away feeling smarter, not used up by another 24/7 loudmouth getting their material from the rumor mill.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 1/3/2020 Harv UK listener

Such a good podcast! Love Mikes perspective, keep it up bro
view on Apple Podcasts

on 8/29/2019 Good listen

Mets fan trying to stay up to date out of market. Good listen for that.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 8/13/2019 Good podcast but upgrade mic plz

I had to max volume just to hear mike. I hope he fixes sound issue. But overall great podcast
view on Apple Podcasts

on 8/12/2019 4 Stars

Solid & thorough podcast, covering all things NYM. Spot on take on the sorry job done by a lot of the media covering the club.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 8/8/2019 Perfect

Mike does a great show. I look forward to it every week. I haven’t lived in NY for many years but have been a Mets fan since the beginning.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 8/8/2019 Most Legit Metspod

I listen to 7 or 8 weekly MetsPods and Mike is definitely the best there is. Don’t take my word for it, just ask my dad who has intermittently sampled several of them and exclaimed that Mike is obviously the most professional and informative host there is.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 5/27/2019 Truth

Mike is a voice of reason when it comes to the Mets. The mainstream media in NY wants to cause disfunction when it comes to the Mets and Mike cuts right through all the BS. That being said, Mike isn’t afraid to call the team out when it’s warranted. This is a must listen weekly for any true Mets fan, who wants honest takes without the media spin.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 3/27/2019 No easy way out reporting

Most sporting news focus on drama and not the sport. You get some news on drama but what you really get is amazing interviews and Mets news!!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 2/27/2019 Silva lining

Mike Silva knows his stuff Good demeanor, pleasant listen
view on Apple Podcasts

on 12/20/2018 Best Mets podcast

Best and most topical Mets podcast available. A must listen for the diehard Mets fan
view on Apple Podcasts

on 5/18/2018 Real talk from real fans!

These guys bring it real with a true pulse of frustrated die hard met fans ...super knowledgeable and passionate , I always look forward to this podcast , as it’s one of the best in town.. thanks guys!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 4/18/2018 Love the show!!! Just...

...turn up your microphone, Mike!!!Lemme hear that great insight a little louder! Your guests are consistently at a decent mic level but then you’re so faint. Thanks man. LGM.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 3/22/2018 Love this podcast

Mike Silva does a great job hear been listening to him for a while and while the show has changed over time this is the best incarnation. Mike knows his Mets he is fair and honest not condescending to the listeners and very informed put that together with a good selection of guests and you have a winner. Keep them coming Mike enjoying every one
view on Apple Podcasts

on 1/5/2018 TOP PODCAST

Great podcast mike .its good to be able to keep up wth all thats happening during the off season Keep up the great work Steve from Cairns Australia
view on Apple Podcasts

on 5/1/2017 Best Mets podcast on the internet

Hands down the best. Can't get enough of it. I check the website several times daily and can't wait for Sunday's to download the podcast.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 4/3/2017 Let's Go Mets

All Mets all the time. Good solid Mets podcast.
view on Apple Podcasts

on 3/21/2017 Mets podcast review

Great insight into the mets and baseball in general, definitely should give it a listen, you won't be disappointed! #LetsGoMets
view on Apple Podcasts

on 7/26/2010 I enjoy your show from Switzerland!

You're doing a great job! Thank you!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 2/28/2010 let hughes start

agreeing with Neil here- phil hughes should be the fifth start....good listen, go yanks!
view on Apple Podcasts

on 1/12/2010 I think this podcast is good.

I like Mike Silva even though he's a Mets fans. He doesn't show his hate for the Yankees(I'm a Yankees fan) like other sports talk show hosts in NY aka Steve Somers(I like him though lol). To the other comment, I feel Mike Silva talks about both Yankees and Mets evenly.
view on Apple Podcasts